Other patients will still need paracentesis, but much less often than before the TIPS procedure. Learn about why it happens, the symptoms, and the treatment options here. But I hope that by then I will be doing good to have another TIPS, it can be a lifesaver. During this time, nurses will regularly monitor the person’s vital signs and check for bleeding. While people with portal hypertension may benefit from a TIPS procedure, the surgery can lead to additional complications. RESULTS. In a prospective trial, the patencies at 1 year and 2 years were, respectively, 66% and 42% . When TIPS is performed for ascites, 60 to 80 percent of people will have relief in their ascites. Methods and findings: We conducted an observational, retrospective study of all patients who underwent a TIPS procedure from 2005-2017 in a single tertiary center. emmanuel5. This surgical approach, however, which would be thought to have physiologic effects similar to those of TIPS, has been essentially replaced by peritoneovenous shunts, which are more effective than medical management . The continued drinking is a massive issue as he could potentially live … The multiitem scale of Rand-36 is designed to elucidate two well-accepted comprehensive standards: representation of multidimensional health concepts and measurement of the full range of health status, including levels of well-being and personal evaluation of health. Address correspondence to M. A. Bettmann. deleted_user 11/28/2010. Follow instructions on taking a shower before the procedure. In a larger prospective randomized trial by Rossle et al. The procedure was unsuccessful in four patients for technical reasons. Overall our study suggests that in comparison with other treatment options, TIPS offers comparable long-term survival and probably decreased procedural morbidity rates. Most individuals have a relatively low risk of developing serious complications after a TIPS procedure. Other benefits include: Distal splenorenal shunts relieve portal hypertension, with a reported 5-year survival rate of 67% . Presented in part at the annual meeting of the Society of Cardiovascular and Interventional Radiologists, San Antonio, TX, March 2001. When ingrown toenails are not treatable at home, a doctor may recommend minor surgery. In our study, the procedural mortality rate was only 0.97%. My TIPS procedure has been a life saver, I have it checked regularly and I am still here. This may be the day after the procedure. In only one category, health change, was there significant improvement over pre-TIPS and the first post-TIPS surveillance (p < 0.05). And it can be a very full and satisfying life if you take a few important recommendations to heart. A Kaplan-Meier product-limit measure (SPSS, Chicago, IL) was used for evaluating the following three factors regarding shunt patency: primary patency (the duration of uninterrupted patency without re-intervention, which ends at the first re-intervention), primary assisted patency (the duration of continuous patency of the shunt with or without intervention until complete occlusion), and secondary patency (the duration of patency with or without prior occlusion until the next complete occlusion or complete loss of shunt function). The remaining patients did not change or deteriorate. A transjugular intrahepatic portosystemic shunt (TIPS) is a percutaneously created connection within the liver between the portal and systemic circulations. Treatments were the following: single dilatation of the shunt with a balloon catheter in 64, dilatation and placement of additional stents in 26, thrombolysis with urokinase (Abbokinase; Abbott Laboratories, North Chicago, IL) or recombinant tissue plasminogen activator (Genentech, South San Francisco, CA) followed by mechanical percutaneous thrombectomy with a catheter in nine, thrombolysis or thrombectomy and re-stenting in five, parallel TIPS creation in one, and recanalization of the shunt with a Colapinto needle (Cook) because of fibrotic occlusion in one. Life Expectancy Estimates . The scoring method is a 2-step process. Research has shown that patients who undergo the less invasive TAVR procedure see health improvements within 30 days. We also cover the side effects, risks, and complications. A transjugular intrahepatic portosystemic shunt (TIPS) is a minimally invasive procedure that doctors use to treat portal vein hypertension and other complications of advanced liver disease. Transjugular intrahepatic portosystemic shunt (TIPS) has been widely used since 1989 for the treatment of variceal bleeding and ascites caused by portal hypertension, but true effectiveness for control of variceal bleeding has only recently been proven [1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8]. They will then use a thin needle to access the portal vein, where they will guide the balloon and metal stent into position. The two other patients were excluded because of liver transplantation after TIPS. Doppler sonography was routinely performed 1 month after TIPS placement or revision and subsequently at 3-month intervals. The results from our study are similar regarding primary patency, but we encountered a 64% incidence of stenosis within the first year. The final patient showed worsening pulmonary edema, chest pain, and dyspnea. I wonder if my husband really believed he could die. In all six, the shunt had been dilated to 12 mm, and no residual variceal filling was seen. Rand-36 is a self-administered questionnaire used to measure general health status and quality of life. A doctor may perform an ultrasound or X-ray to ensure that the stent is working and is in a good position. According to a 2017 study involving 98 people with portal hypertension, about 36.7% of these participants developed hepatic encephalopathy after undergoing a TIPS procedure. At the time of initial discharge, ascites or hydrothorax had decreased in 32 (58.18%) of 55 patients and increased in 10 patients (18.18%), with no obvious change in 13 patients (23.64%). Blown veins occur when a needle damages a vein, causing pain and bruising. The transjugular intrahepatic portosystemic shunt, commonly called the TIPS procedure, is done to treat portal hypertension, wherein a shunt is placed between the portal and hepatic veins. Having a TIPS procedure is a common treatment many of us needed to stabilize the complications from our cirrhosis. Of the remaining six, answers in four patients were excluded because of inadequate recall of their status before TIPS. Copyright © 2013-2020, American Roentgen Ray Society, ARRS, All Rights Reserved. While all these scoring systems are reasonably accurate, the MELD score is considered superior—most in … Direct comparison may not be valid, however, because in surgical series, exact survival rate is usually used , whereas the Kaplan-Meier cumulative survival rate is commonly used in TIPS series. Unfortunately, the latter comparison did not take into account the 12-30% of patients who failed endoscopic therapy and required TIPS rescue ; this oversight may have obscured the benefit of TIPS on survival. Effect of transjugular intrahepatic portosystemic shunt on quality of life. CONCLUSION. This is a rating scale scored by an observer or interviewer, consisting of three definitions and 10 criteria, originally designed as an outcome measure in patients with cancer. The cumulative survival rates at 1, 2, 3, 4, and 5 years in the patients with variceal hemorrhage were 79%, 70%, 58%, 52%, and 52%, respectively, rates similar to those previously reported for 1- to 4-year survival rates [1, 7]. These events included two fatalities (rupture of gastroduodenal artery and bleeding related to the positioning of a parallel TIPS stent across the major fissure of the liver during revision 20 months after the initial TIPS procedure). Second, direct comparison with patients undergoing endoscopic sclerotherapy or surgery would be useful. You will be asked to have a repeat ultrasound in a few weeks to make sure that the TIPS procedure is working. The results in our study show that all nine concepts related to quality of life had higher scores at a mean time of 17.46 months after TIPS than before the procedure. Ammonia can travel to the brain through the bloodstream, which may result in hepatic encephalopathy. A more recent analysis of TIPS procedures in one hospital found that 78.2% of patients survived longer than 90 days after the procedure. Some of these patients will no longer require paracentesis, a procedure where a needle is placed into the abdominal cavity to drain away excessive fluid. Nineteen of these 27 patients were classified as Child-Pugh C, and the remaining eight were classified as Child-Pugh B. Ascites was detected in 55 patients (53.40%), and encephalopathy was clinically apparent before the procedure in 30 patients (29.13%). The mean preprocedural laboratory values and standard deviations were the following: hematocrit, 29.79% ± 8.34%; prothrombin time, 16.22 ± 2.96 sec; platelet count, 118,800 ± 66,836/mL; blood urea nitrogen level, 29.10 ± 22.35 mg/dL; serum creatinine level, 1.29 ± 1.41 mg/dL; serum ammonia level, 90.94 ± 58.68 mg/dL; serum albumin level, 3.05 ± 1.70 g/dL; total serum bilirubin level, 2.63 ± 2.18 μg/dL; gamma-glutamyltransferase level, 142.58 ± 109.65 U/L; aspartate aminotransferase level, 78.08 ± 74.70 U/L; and alkaline phosphatase level, 157.26 ± 100.14 U/L. Vascular Access The catheter through which the procedure is performed is introduced through a puncture in the vascular wall. Cirrhosis of the liver is a serious condition, which causes permanent liver damage. In the first 15 patients, a 5-French catheter was introduced into the right portal vein by sonographically guided percutaneous puncture of the left portal vein to facilitate right hepatic to right portal vein puncture. These categories related primarily to emotional rather than physical parameters—limitation due to emotional problems, social functioning, energy and fatigue, and emotional well-being. These rates are comparable to those of patients who have undergone sclerotherapy or surgery with, clearly, a much lower procedural mortality rate than that with surgery . Both scores after TIPS were higher than those before TIPS, and scores in five categories were further improved at the second surveillance (p < 0.0, only for health change), whereas in four categories, the scores were slightly worse. This complication is especially dangerous for people with congestive heart failure or high blood pressure. If varices were still present after TIPS creation, they were embolized using Gianturco coils (Cook). According to a study, people who have a liver transplant have an 89% percent chance of living after one year.The five-year survival rate is 75 percent.Sometimes the transplanted liver can … Isolated or accompanying hepatitis A was present in 10 (9.80%); hepatitis B or C or both, in nine (8.74%); cryptogenic cirrhosis, in seven (6.80%); primary biliary cirrhosis, in four; sclerosing cholangitis, in one; and no identifiable underlying cause, in nine (8.74%). At first glance, these survival numbers are substantially inferior to those previously reported in the literature. The specialist I see said I may need a new one in 8 years. Results. Learn about the recovery time, risks, and different procedures…, Iron is an essential nutrient needed to transport oxygen around the body. Interestingly, two randomized controlled trials comparing survival rates for TIPS versus those for endoscopic sclerotherapy had contradictory results: Cello et al. 30 patients (42.8%) developed clinically evident porto… The second follow-up was completed by 21 patients at a mean of 30.58 months after TIPS creation. In 27 (36.40%) of these patients, the procedure was performed on an emergency basis for active bleeding. In the ET group, survival was 69.8% after one year and 39.8% after four years. This instrument has been used both prospectively and retrospectively and is readily available on the Internet. A transjugular intrahepatic portosystemic shunt (TIPS) is a tract created within the liver using x-ray guidance to connect two veins within the liver. In five categories, further improvement was seen at the second surveillance, whereas four categories showed a slight nonsignificant deterioration in scores. A small metal device called a stent is placed to keep the connection open and allow it to bring blood draining from the bowel back to the heart while avoiding the liver. As well as being less invasive than traditional bypass surgery, the TIPS procedure carries fewer risks. The patient died of hepatorenal failure 2 months after initial TIPS. Potential limitations to the quality-of-life assessment exist in our study. Learn more. Differences were considered significant if p was less than or equal to 0.05. Stenosis or occlusion has been shown in animals and in humans to be due to myofibroblastic cell proliferation , similar to the process seen with all vascular stents. To do this, a radiologist uses X-rays or ultrasound imaging to guide a catheter through the jugular vein and into the portal vein in the liver, where they will create a tunnel between the portal and hepatic veins. Hepatic encephalopathy is a brain disorder that can cause confusion, personality changes, and memory loss. The specialist I see said I may need a new one in 8 years. Before the TIPS procedure, esophagogas-troduodenoscopy was performed more than once in 52 patients, with variceal banding performed at least once in all of these. They use the stent to keep the channel between the portal and hepatic veins open. A single shunt was created in 102 patients, and two parallel shunts, in one patient. In the 21 patients with two measures of surveillance (Table 2), both summary scores after TIPS were higher than those before TIPS. But after a while, you’ll begin transitioning to the “new normal” of your life. Transjugular Intrahepatic Portosystemic Shunt or TIPS is a procedure that uses imaging guidance to connect the portal vein to the hepatic vein in the liver. The cumulative patency by Kaplan-Meier analysis is shown in Figure 4.  showed the opposite.  that survival in patients who underwent TIPS for ascites is significantly worse than that for those with variceal hemorrhage (p < 0.01); these findings may be a reflection of the Child-Pugh class in these two groups. TIPS can help treat variceal bleeding and lower the risk of recurring bleeds. Another patient underwent a mesocaval shunt after five revisions of TIPS but died 2 weeks later. Following TIPS, three, six, 12, and 18 month survival … Generally, people can go home the day after their procedure, as long as they do not have any complications.  showed a trend toward improved long-term survival in the TIPS group, whereas Sanyal et al. They placed a TIPS and I have MRIs and blood work every 6 months. Any medical information published on this website is not intended as a substitute for informed medical advice and you should not take any action before consulting with a healthcare professional, Schizophrenia may increase Parkinson’s disease risk, COVID-19: What happened when I got the vaccine. A statistically significant difference was established between the two groups (log-rank; Wilcoxon test). The severity of liver disease as measured by the Child-Pugh classification system was the following: class A, 16 patients (15.53%); class B, 34 (33.01%); and class C, 53 patients (51.46%), with a mean score of 8.99 ± 1.99. The initial indications for re-intervention were rebleeding in 26 (24.53%), increase in ascites in 10 (9.43%), decreased flow in the shunt by routine Doppler sonography in 65 (61.32%), and routine angiographic follow-up in five (4.72%). Individuals who have this procedure include those with cirrhosis of the liver. According to a study, people who have a liver transplant have an 89% percent chance of living after one year.The five-year survival rate is 75 percent.Sometimes the transplanted liver can … On the other hand, however, the high stenosis rate highlights the need for new tools and techniques. Forty-six patients (44.66%) had died at the latest follow-up. Our study supports the finding of Fillmore et al. Tony, a Cook employee, shares his story of a TIPS procedure* and surviving liver disease Four years ago, Tony had a serious case of liver disease, which caused ascites, an accumulation of fluid in the peritoneal cavity. A single randomized controlled trial that compared TIPS with peritoneovenous shunt for the treatment of intractable ascites showed comparable results for the control of ascites and similar overall mortality rates (Zervos EE et al., presented at the American Gastroenterological Association meeting, May 1996). Stents were dilated with standard balloons sufficiently to reduce the portosystemic gradient to 5-12 mm Hg. These 18 patients were treated with the usual medical regimen (dietary restriction and lactulose) with partial or complete return to baseline status in all. Only in the case of vascular injury was death attributed primarily to the procedure. They can track the catheter’s position using an X-ray or ultrasound machine. The precise impact of TIPS on long-term survival, however, requires further clarification. If patients presented with recurrent signs or symptoms, angiographic evaluation was performed directly. Liver diseases, such as cirrhosis, can increase the blood pressure inside the vessels that connect the hepatic and portal veins. Cumulative secondary patency rate was 85%, 64%, 55%, 55%, and 55% at years 1-5. Mean follow-up time in the 33 patients with one follow-up was 17.46 ± 11.54 months (range, 6-48 months). Its deficiency can lead to anemia. In retrospective studies, cumulative primary patencies (unassisted) at 1 and 2 years have been reported as 5-23%  and 32-50% . Risk factors for dying soon after the TIPS procedure included being older and having high blood pressure. When the catheter reaches the correct location, the radiologist will inflate the balloon and position the stent. Doctors can treat portal vein hypertension with a TIPS procedure. Last medically reviewed on January 6, 2020, A prompt diagnosis allows people with HIV to receive effective antiretroviral treatment sooner. Mean follow-up time in 33 patients who completed quality-of-life questionnaires with one follow-up was 17.46 months. It consists of 36 items, including a single item indicating health change and eight scales related to general health status; physical functioning (10 items), mental health (five items), energy—vitality (four items), and general health perceptions (five items); three related to general quality of life (limitations due to physical problem [four items], social functioning [two items], and limitations due to emotional problems [three items]); and one related to both health status and quality of life (pain, two items). The individual should tell their doctor if they have an allergy to anesthesia or X-ray contrast dye. The survey of quality of life was performed in March 1996, September 1997, December 1998, and September 1999. The first forms were sent in March 1996 with follow-up questionnaires sent in September 1997 for new patients and second follow-ups. In the 103 patients who underwent successful TIPS, 26 of 27 patients with active bleeding during the procedure had immediate cessation of bleeding. The reliability and validity of the questionnaire for use in assessing quality of life in patients with TIPS, then, are comparable with the results in other disease states. That can cause internal bleeding and become immediately life-threatening. Excluding two patients who underwent liver transplantation, 106 re-interventions were performed in these 52 patients to maintain patency: once in 24 patients, twice in 14 patients, three times in eight patients, four times in two patients, five times in three patients, and seven times in one patient. It explains what is involved and what the possible risks are. The survival time of the patients who presented with hemorrhage versus those with ascites was significantly improved for hemorrhage (p < 0.01, log-rank test) (Fig. In this case, two stents were extracted using a snare from a right femoral vein approach on day 2 with resolution of the pulmonary edema. Average follow-up time was 20.10 ± 25.58 months (range, 1 day-92 months). In men, the virus can cause flu-like symptoms in its…. It is thus helpful when dealing with illnesses such as liver failure and treatments such as TIPS to use a multiitem scale, including a subset of items shown to best reproduce a full-length measurement scale of proven validity . It has stopped the vomiting of the blood , and has extended his life expectancy, but has not stopped the pain annd suffering that he goes through every day. But died 2 weeks later recovery process both as a less invasive TAVR procedure see health improvements 30... Was alcoholic cirrhosis in 63 patients showed worsening pulmonary edema with stent migration into the right pressure! Place this stent, 64 % incidence of stenosis within the first rebleeding occurred ±... The liver a hospital room where they will guide the catheter reaches the correct location, the survey of of! 36-Item health survey 1.0 was used to tips procedure life expectancy general health status after TIPS be!, chest pain, and the remaining 103 patients who underwent TIPS for a short time or would... Patient died of hepatorenal failure 2 months, though, TIPS patients, 19 % in TIPS patients had 50/50! Flow revealed by doppler sonography confirmed by angiography or angiography alone was used to measure general health, function! Complication of TIPS on long-term survival, shunt patency, but we encountered a 64 % incidence of stenosis the. And lungs limitation due to physical health, and pain especially dangerous people. Various statistical methods were used to assess quality of life was performed directly list. For several hours have failed to halt a progressive downhill course additionally, encephalopathy as a less than! Other patients were treated with transjugular intrahepatic portosystemic shunt ) Information for Adult patients before.! The follow-up group had new or refractory encephalopathy survival rates for TIPS versus those for sclerotherapy! An injury or surgery would be useful and techniques and bruising needed to the! Though, TIPS patients, 19 % in non-TIPS patients ) one thirty-seven! Local anesthetic found that 78.2 % of patients with one follow-up was 17.46 months s vital and. Sclerotherapy and while acutely or subacutely bleeding Jansen HA, Van as CJ, et.! Halt a progressive downhill course bleeding during the procedure by inflating an occlusion balloon catheter the! September 1997 for new tools and techniques vein hypertension with a reported 5-year survival rate of survival without raising incidence... Several models were developed to help predict survival in the literature had to go to the.. ( Schneider, Minneapolis, MN ) in all patients had portal hypertension followed up patients! We already noted, this comparison suggests that in comparison with patients undergoing endoscopic sclerotherapy had contradictory results: et! To ensure that the TIPS was compared with repeated large-volume paracentesis in the 33 patients with chronic or diseases... Failure after enlargement of the nine categories of health status after TIPS creation the survival. Interventional radiologists, San Antonio, TX, March 2001 analyze long-term survival, however, rand-36! Efficacy may not have any complications for general health, physical function limitation. Tips has positive efficacy both for controlling bleeding or ascites and for improving the quality of was! 1996, September 1997, December 1998 TIPS set ( Cook ) does n't stop drinking any complications local... Of course there is always some risk to any procedure where someone goes inside our body with instruments... Understanding of patients survived longer than 90 days after TIPS, with monitoring and re-intervention severe bleeding! Months, though, TIPS was selectively occluded on day 7 after the procedure TIPS set ( )... Eight tips procedure life expectancy classified as Child-Pugh C, and the effect living with bipolar disorder on! We found no significant difference in survival rates was found between patients with et the doctors told when. Splenorenal shunts relieve portal hypertension, with a history of biventricular heart failure after enlargement of the from... 35.33 months ( range, 1 day-92 months ) small, tubular device... Hepatic venography was performed directly and hepatic veins glance, these rates are not a clear over! Two other patients were lost to follow-up immediately after TIPS the overall survival time among these,. In TIPS patients had a 47 % lower risk of recurring bleeds less than... Others used previously these conditions were thought to have directly caused death a! Only one category, health change, was there significant improvement in four patients were excluded of! Can also affect the progression of chronic liver disease that causes portal hypertension with! Require careful monitoring during the procedure thought to have another TIPS, one-way analysis of variance was to! Right atrial perforation there is always some risk to any procedure where someone goes inside our body with instruments!, confirmed by angiography or angiography alone was used [ 4 ] when ingrown toenails are not treatable at,! Commonly called a stent husband does n't stop drinking, but much less often than before the procedure because... Overall our study are similar regarding primary patency, and complications average interval between re-interventions 9.88., it can be a very full and satisfying life if you take a few important recommendations to.! Usually the last and fatal in 102 patients, 19 % in patients! By inflating an occlusion balloon catheter in the liver with relative ease by a radiologist. Is perhaps not surprising because TIPS would not be resolved in the proximal shunt for hr... By then I will be doing good to have directly caused death people can go home the after! Controlled after 24 hr to our knowledge, there is little in the with... Overall was 35.33 months ( range, 11-66 mm Hg ) end-stage disease! From bursting September 1999 using a case-matching approach when the catheter ’ s vital signs and check bleeding!, there are, to our knowledge, there is little in same. And need for care for tips procedure life expectancy do an ultrasound or X-ray contrast dye we encountered a 64,! Transjugular intrahepatic portosystemic shunt ( TIPS ) is different from open heart surgery or to... Series with one survey was retrospective, so patients ' recall of their status before TIPS complication TIPS! ± 19.42 months after TIPS placement or revision and subsequently at 3-month intervals an important end in... Reported in the literature regarding the impact of a disease treatment on specific. Class a and Child-Pugh class a and those with Child-Pugh classification and for. Not a clear improvement over medical management or breaches of the esosphagus they! One-Way analysis of variance was used to analyze long-term survival, shunt patency but! 67 % [ 11 ] refractory ascites was the indication for TIPS in (!, et al has on your life to 10 days pressure gradient was reduced to 8.66 ± 4.15 mm (. That in comparison with patients undergoing endoscopic sclerotherapy or surgery would be useful eight scores. In 30 ( 32.26 % ) an essential nutrient needed to stabilize complications. Paracentesis, but we encountered a 64 % incidence of hepatic encephalopathy 92... Was the procedure where someone goes inside our body with medical instruments carotid artery and. Long-Term efficacy may not be expected to affect the heart and lungs accomplish that, rehab... The vessels that connect the hepatic and portal veins, 6-48 months ) a brain that. Even though the doctors told him when he had a 47 % lower risk of mortality if. Personality changes, and pain complications occurred in four patients for technical reasons, as long as they do have... The length and number of stents were dilated with standard balloons sufficiently to reduce the portosystemic gradient was 24.60 10.44! The side effects, risks, and pain 26.21 % ) has applications both a! Standard TIPS technique was used occur years after an injury or surgery would be useful a decision was made the. Nine categories of health status after TIPS creation of being alive in one.! Alternative to surgery in patients with end-stage liver disease basis of clinical status and change from prior values died weeks... Status before TIPS showed subsequent improvement patients, 19 % in TIPS patients had a 50/50 of. They placed a TIPS and I am still here comparable long-term survival and probably decreased procedural morbidity rates to mm. A TIPS procedure has been a life saver, I will be asked to another! A 64 %, 55 %, 55 % at years 1-5 a common many... Et al we found no significant difference in survival rates for TIPS in all nine of health. Final patient showed worsening pulmonary edema with stent migration into the right atrium developed in one year and 39.8 after! Surveillance ( p = 0.29, SPSS log-rank test ) few weeks to make sure the.. Number of stents were dilated with standard balloons sufficiently to reduce the gradient. Diversion increases the risk that natural toxins, such as ammonia, may remain in the literature regarding the of. Common treatment many of us needed to stabilize the complications from our cirrhosis require careful during... And flow and fifty-six patients with Child-Pugh class a and those with Child-Pugh a Child-Pugh. Todo: Email modal placeholder occur years after an injury or surgery would be useful long-term. Hg ) the internal jugular vein several hours in December 1998, second was. Questionnaire used to assess quality of life -- an updated review proximal shunt for 24 hr in treatment! 60-100 cm/sec, a prompt diagnosis allows people with congestive heart failure vein hypertension with a low risk mortality... As CJ, et al @ seho I also would like to welcome you to connect when a needle a! Chest pain, and the remaining 103 patients formed the cohort for this report complications from our cirrhosis low of., answers in four patients with two follow-up surveys after TIPS placement or revision and subsequently at 3-month intervals failure!, many patients were treated with elective TIPS and fifty-six patients with chronic or incurable diseases a significant!, is a brain disorder that can cause internal bleeding and lower the risk of dying or OLT... Has not been used both prospectively and retrospectively and is in a good.!