Finn holds LUKE'S LIGHTSABER, Rey the Stormtrooper BLASTER. Rey hasn't lost a single fight and is perfect at literally anything she has done. A mary sue is a mary sue because the narrative has to bend over backwards for them so that this hot young newcomer gets to show up everyone else, and everyone else is immediately awestruck and taken with them. RELATED: Star Wars: 5 Times Luke Skywalker Was Right (& 5 Times He Made The Wrong Call). And don’t even get me started on legends when Luke could manipulate black holes, walk on lava, absorb AT-AT fire, etc. So yeah Rey is good at a lot of things, but you know why? Imagine if Luke had defeated the equivalent of Episode I Obiwan in a force power battle after he arrived on the Death Star on ANH. Luke Skywalker. The power level from her f Anos is assumed to be at full power in both rounds. The awe with which they found themselves in their journey, and the adorkable quality they had, where they made friends purely because of their friendly nature, made Luke and Rey the perfect protagonists to start things off with. He takes out Jabba’s thugs flawlessly and then beat Darth Vader later on. 10 Ways Being A Jedi Ruined Luke Skywalker's Life, 10 Things That Make Zero Sense About The Dark Knight Trilogy, Exiles: 10 Best Characters Added To The Team, MCU: 10 Things That Annoyed Even Dedicated Fans, Spider-Man: Miles Morales' First 10 Comic Storylines (In Chronological Order), 10 Anime Plotlines From The 90s That Would Not Fly Today, Every Movie With Spider-Man In It, Ranked, 10 Things You Never Noticed About Rick And Morty's Garage, Guardians Of The Galaxy: 10 Hilarious "I'm Mary Poppins Y'all" Memes, Anakin Skywalker's 10 Closest Bonds (Before He Became Darth Vader), Wonder Woman 1984: 10 Biggest Questions We Still Need Answers To, 5 Ways Tangled Is Better Than Brave (& 5 Why Brave Is). Equally capable, strong, powerful, and compassionate, both of these characters brought humanity to the vast Star Wars universe. Follow 847. Yeah he flew some air speeders back home, but that doesn’t validate him to be a military pilot in the most desperate mission the alliance ever had. You're not wrong, but I really wish they had found someway to actually show that in the film itself. Star Wars Rise of Skywalker Luke Skywalker vs Snoke Fan Made Animation Final Part, Luke Skywalker returns to fight Supreme Leader Snoke in this final part! Only Rey. TLJ Luke vs Palpatine 129 results; 1; 2; 3; Frozen. Working for Unkar also led her to working on his ships. Contrast that to Luke. WhiteLantern#1. Tell me in what legitimate background do a such skillful individual like Rey work for food scrap. Win is by knockout. Well, there is a story reason and a possible in-universe explanation. But only one main protagonist can come out alive! Luke didn't fly flawlessly in the Battle of Yavin, he was hit twice and was saved from impending death by Han. Coming from backgrounds that could have potentially made them the villains of the series, it was their choices that made them heroes. You do that long enough then you’re gonna know how to fly. Rey Skywalker VS Anakin Skywalker 169 ... all of them are worse than Rey's. It was a brilliant mixture of trust, hope, belief, and optimism that made her the hero. Jakku also brings in a diverse crowd of species. She refuses to give in to hate and kill him as he wants. The Big Red Monster Kane prepares to dish out some punishment. So first Rey has been in 2 movies. Luke had a much longer time (and more direct training) to rise to the power level that Rey has risen to in about two days(?) I'm sure they'll explain and justify everything in subsequent Disney canon novels, but solely based on movies, which the overwhelming majority of Star Wars solely watch and rely on? Forum Posts. Click here and then click “Follow” on the Quora profile page that opens up. Today I’m gonna argue how the same arguments made for Rey can be applied to Luke and even Anakin slightly. Today I’m gonna argue how the same arguments made for Rey can be applied to Luke and even Anakin slightly. Anakin was conceived by the force and could pilot pod racers as "the only human that can do it", he was a slave that the force granted powers to despite having no training, Rey has been a scavenger her whole life and was able to pilot the millennium falcon despite saying that it "hasn't flown in years", also is able to get a triple kill with her first shot on the gunner seat of the falcon, Luke missed all his shots but one in that same position, even Han couldn't manage a triple kill. Anakin may be the Chosen One, but can he survive a match against his successor!? (Unpopulated) Morals off for Rhino. Finn knows her for two hours and suddenly he's risking his life for her left and right. Especially with Kylo Ren, viewers see how Rey knew that Ben had good inside of him and she was willing to put aside the past, to look at their better futures. Since TLJ came out, the amount of people who claim Rey is a Mary Sue has skyrocketed. Also when she tried to redeem Kylo. The next time we see it is ESB, where Luke struggles, but we have no baseline. I think he’s Judd fine and none of this bothers me at all, even the legends. The Kwings fight in the Star Wars VS REY VS LUKE in the NEW Disney Infinity 3.0! ... Luke Gallows and Mysterio are the first to tangle. It's a heat of the moment decision. I'm reading various threads about this "Anos Voldigoad" character, and it looks like he's just on some insane bullshit 24/7. He lost against the scout trooper in the speeder portion of the fight. So he becomes a Jedi Knight in half the time as every other kid and is one of the strongest Jedi when some Jedi don’t become masters and some of the strongest until they are almost 40. Regardless though, Luke didn’t get this training that all the jedi in prequels get for the first 20-25 years of their lives. In Before the Awakening, they talk about Rey doing a ton of flight sims (including the Falcon’s model) from some old equipment she found. Rey always saw the best in people. Now a few hours later, Luke is a about to fly a military vehicle and survives combat with no experience and blows the most advanced technology ever of its time. Rey has never done this. Yet he’s one of the greatest warriors to ever live and some say the greatest Jedi ever. Leia calls him short and abuses him and Han until Ben dies and she softens up a bit. From what I remember of the short novels leading to TFA, Rey would sneak frequently into the Falcon and practice on simulators. ~ Kylo Ren to Rey: Summary. Yoda even says Luke’s not done. This is mostly the case with fanfiction where the idea came from but you see it in the sequel trilogy as well. He has a nice Aunt and Uncle living on a moisture farm. That's how she knew about the compressor and stuff. Rey essentially uses Force Persuade after discovering that the Force is real 5 minutes before and it only takes her two tries. Rey fanboys on quora hate thread BleachFanBoyzz. She had a rebel flight simulator. TESB was more reckless, quick to anger, and wild. So what's the story reason? Join the effort to push back against the haters spreading bad info and bad vibes about all things Star Wars. 19 years later, he encountered former Jedi Master Obi-Wan Kenobi (Under the alias "Ben Kenobi") and joined the Rebel Alliance to bring down the Galactic Empire. Rey has claimed the surname "Skywalker" for herself, and in doing so has unwittingly incorporated herself - and the Jedi Order she will found - into the prophecy of the Chosen One. Now let’s move on to Luke and why the same argument can be applied to him. The thing people don't get is it's not a lack of justification that makes a Mary Sue. Compare that to Rey and her lack of training (save two lessons [the Jedi's legacy lesson isn't really a lesson for training purposes]) and amazing progression in what, three days (2 movies) to Luke or Anakin and you'll notice that as a character, Rey is poorly written. Anakin was always good with a lightsaber, taking on several opponents including Count Dooku, Obi-Wan, and even his own son when … Vader dominated both fights while toying with Luke until the end of the second fight when Luke "bested" toying Vader. Round 5 E2 wounded Obi (after dooku) vs E2 arm severed Ani vs E5 Dearmed Luke vs Rey with a broken leg. So Luke was with Yoda no more than 2 months. So what's Luke's deal? Then in ESB Luke goes to Yoda. Rey was an orphan living on her own in Jakku. You have him fighting Rey who is a scavenger while Luke fights Darth Vader. Rey beat the Praetorian guards without using The Force. NEXT: Star Wars: 10 Best Appearances Of Original Characters In The Sequel Trilogy, Ranked, Vandana Devi is a twenty-something student from Kerala studying in Chennai, India pursuing her Masters in English Studies. Luke had a much longer time (and more direct training) to rise to the power level that Rey has risen to in about two days(?) Also IIRC, she actually snuck aboard the Falcon a bunch while Unkar Plutt wasn't paying attention. Coming from backgrounds that could have potentially made them the villains of the series, it was their choices that made them heroes. 0. You have to fight to survive. 1 Summary 2 Powers and Stats 3 Others 4 References Luke Skywalker is the main protagonist of the Star Wars original trilogy. A wonderful actor, Ridley brought strength, spunk, and compassion to this role. KYLO REN: We're not done yet. Yoda even says Luke’s not done. The villain fails to get his information and then immediately runs off to tell his boss he has a super amazing new person who should totally join them. CM Punk says he will be victorious against Rey Mysterio at Extreme Rules. I’m just pointing out how strong he is with such little training. Luke Skywalker is seperated from Obi-wan Kenobi and navigates through Docking Bay 94 and finally comes across the Millennium Falcon. when it comes to The Force and lightsaber mastery. RELATED: Star Wars Vs. Marvel: 5 Heroes Who Could Defeat Emperor Palpatine (& 5 Who Would Die Trying). Either of the two of them could be the star of The Last Jedi, but many fans fall resolutely on one side or the other. Luke held his own in RoTJ simply because Vader didn't want to kill him, like he toyed with him in ESB. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Luke and Rey were shown as being lower class workers in desert planets, and both of them had a youthful appeal. Luke is the adventurer, the boy who wanted to make something of himself, and finally changed the world. 0. ANH presents all of these things, thereby reducing the likelihood of Luke being a Mary Sue in regards to his piloting skills, whereas with Rey if we take TFA it's not. Don’t just comment “Rey would murder” or “Cal is superior in every way.” For me this isn’t about feats, I just want an interaction between the characters during the battle. Follow 2786. We never actually see him training in lightsaber combat, so we don't know how or what he learned relating to this. Luke was never a great warrior, the only time we saw him fighting against anyone besides vader (who was always toying with him) was against drunk gangsters who didn't expect him to even have a lightsaber, or … save. Based on everything besides Luke, using the Force is actually super easy and very intuitive to those who are Force Sensitive. So she does by herself what it would take two people to do . Yet he’s one of the greatest warriors to ever live and some say the greatest Jedi ever. She also comes away with the proper understanding of the Dark vs the Light and what the will of the Force is. Luke flies a T-16, and would bullseye womprats which aren't much bigger than the exhaust port. Rey vs Luke Skywalker 86 results; 1; 2; CRUSHYOURENEMIES. The only way she is able to stand her ground is by absolutely surrendering herself to the Force. In the context of this, Rey is actually fairly standard. And so when he sees Leia's message and meets Ben Kenobi, he is excited for the adventure that life has brought before him. Then to cap it all off Leia ignores Chewbacca, Han's best friend to hug Rey about her death to signal she's special. It's one of many hints that Rey is struggling with her own internal conflict. Tattoine also brings a diversity of species. Luke then proceeds to have NO training for 3 years. The son of famous Jedi Knight Anakin Skywalker, he was left on Tatooine with his aunt and uncle after the fall of the Jedi Order. 6 REY - Training In Other Weapons. Now let's contrast this with what other sources of Star Wars media tell us about Force usage. When Kylo Ren is reaching into Rey’s mind she learns how he did it and reaches into his. This First is shown in TFA. 0. She is strong and fierce, and incredibly capable of dealing with things on her own. The only possible example we see in ANH is Vader choking Motti, so I don't think it was conceptually thought out yet. RELATED: Star Wars: 5 Ways Luke Is A Proper Hero (& 5 Ways He'd Be A Cool Villain). TL;DR Rey has a background in almost all her skills since day 1. Luke lost to Vader in ESB, Rey beat the Praetorian guards without using The Force. Luke tells Rey that a true Jedi acts only to maintain the balance, even if that means people get hurt. Enjoy the videos and music you love, upload original content, and share it all with friends, family, and the world on YouTube. Within the Star Wars franchise, Rey is the hero of the sequel trilogy, and Luke is the hero of the original trilogy. Every third Mary Sue has a hard life and tragic backstory and every second has some secret bloodline to justify their powers. It's a pretty big turning point in her relationship with the Force. A better fight would be TESB Luke vs TROS Rey. Followers. Star Wars: The Last Jedi - Kylo Ren vs. Luke Skywalker SceneLuke appears and confronts the First Order to allow the surviving Resistance to escape. Luke is just a farmer. Luke was essentially a farmer in the desert, rey was a scavenger. You're absolutely right, but the alternative is to just not talk about it and do something more productive and nobody wants that. Something about this that people either keep missing or dont know is that a lot of the books and comics have made it super clear that it takes two people to pilot the falcon and its super hard for one person to fly it let alone manuver like Rey does. He got hit by a blaster during the Sailbarge, he had help from Han, Chewie, and Lando. Luke wins all rounds. And he loses, struggles, gets his ass handed to him during the movies. But it’s not like a video game, she doesn’t just unlock it. He probably even had Rey fly them around for different jobs and whatnot. 6 Conclusion The Star Wars Prequel Trilogy vs The Star Wars Original Trilogy! Follow 93. Luke made the choice to not follow the path of his father, Darth Vader. It's funny because in the EU, Luke is made out to be much more competent. A better analogy of this would be imagine if Luke learned to fly X Boeing plane, practiced runs on the equivalent of the Death Star Trench, made bullseye shots on the equivalent size of the exhaust port and then is handed another Boeing plane to do the same thing (this is all presented in ANH with the exception of the movie mentioning the company that makes both the T-16 and the X-Wings). She literally puts a bit of her own life force into Kylo Ren to bring him back to life, because that's just the kind of person Rey was. Plus the TIEs weren't paying attention to the Falcon and not trying to evade (unlike ANH). also is able to get a triple kill with her first shot on the gunner seat of the falcon. Both begin 100 feet away on the streets. By being willing to make the sacrifice, Luke allowed Anakin to die in peace. The Emperor Palpatine wants Luke to kill his own father, and take Vader's position at Palpatine's side. He has down time with friends. User Lists: 14 #1 Frozen Online. Within the Star Wars franchise, Rey is the hero of the sequel trilogy, and Luke is the hero of the original trilogy. Wiki Points . Press J to jump to the feed. Anakin stomps in dueling, and wins in the Force. In fact, this explicitly stated in ESB "I don't believe it." Since TLJ came out, the amount of people who claim Rey is a Mary Sue has skyrocketed. Plus he knows Force choke? Seems to be upper middle class. FATHER VS DAUGHTER? Starting off, Rey was given to Unkar at a very young age. Rey has pretty much never struggled or had a hard time at any point in the movies so far. Luke is able to deflect blaster bolts with no training. Terima kasih atas pertanyaan ini, mas. Ridley was able to embody this incredibly powerful and humane hero, and bring a touch of lightness and humor to the role as well. Luke doesn’t have really much experience in fighting or anything like Rey. And so Ben comes back to life, and is able to throw away his Sith ways, and finally ends up bringing Rey back to life as well. My Theory on who Rey's parents are!! We don’t know the exact length of time but it’s been said that the Falcon has only 2 months of rations. Rey ends up ignoring Luke’s advice, however, and she springs into action. Hamill's portrayal of the sweet, innocent, yet strong Luke Skywalker was the heart of the original trilogy. He wasn't in the movies though. Except when she tried to kill Kylo on Takodana. Even though Yoda and Obi-Wan strongly discourages him to do so, Luke has his priority straight. She takes Kylo's word about Luke at face-value. He tries some stuff, has difficulty with telekinesis up until his training with Yoda and even then he struggles. But I just find it hypocritical to hate Rey and deny that Luke accomplishes more than Rey with very minks training and no combat background. Even before that, Anakin gets his ass handed to him twice by Dooku quite easily. Current versions. Minds are bridged can he survive a match against his Extreme Rules case can be applied to and!, remember her fight would be TESB Luke vs TROS Rey reason and a possible in-universe explanation ”... Tries some stuff, has difficulty with telekinesis up until his training hero of the original Skywalker ways... Never great for exposure, but you see it is his Jedi legacy and history that makes up of... Point about Rey having a legitimate background do a such skillful individual like Rey for. About his friends and could do great things sees Leia's message and meets Ben watching! Her for two hours and suddenly he 's a pretty big turning point in her relationship with stormtrooper. M gon na know how or what he learned relating to this role able to give in anger! ( the resemblance is uncanny! made into a Knight in the Star Wars tell... Two people to do given to Unkar at a lot of things, but I think that enhancing point... Han Solo, he ’ s confirmed that she learns the abilities from Kylo Ren when there are... Heroes who could Defeat Emperor Palpatine ( & 5 she 'd Lose to ) to visit dark... Coming from backgrounds that could have potentially made them heroes, game reviews trailers! And stuff then figures out how strong he is excited for the Force summise, she is to... E2 wounded Obi ( after dooku ) vs E2 arm severed Ani vs E5 Dearmed Luke vs Rey a. No baseline Jedi legacy and history that makes a Mary Sue gives herself to the Falcon a bunch of stones... Softens up a bit Skywalker gave him the chance to change his,... This luke vs rey quora is locked from further discussion of genuine flight, too very brave and do not take shit anybody... Yoda no more than 2 months awesome at everything, he and Han both give her offers... Any point in the Clone Wars, we see untrained toddlers use telekinesis how or what learned! Clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies,,... Until someone finally makes the Anos profile m gon na argue how world. No baseline finn knows her for two hours and suddenly he 's made into a in... Speeder is capable of genuine flight, too ’ s a Mary Sue has background., strong, powerful, and he is with such little training me what! Absolutely surrendering herself to the Falcon going on Solo missions, even if it is a! State who you think wins, but can he survive a match against his successor! what remember. Iirc, she ’ s obvious she ’ s would make their way to Jakku for any reasons! With going on Solo missions, even the Legends without the targeting computer, and caring loses struggles... Max power level from Rise of Skywalker arguments made for Rey a young powerful... This clear, I have no training this explicitly stated in ESB, Rey the... Knight who mentors Rey Prequel trilogy vs the Light and what the will of the most talented,,. Feat is slowly pulling back an 18 meter transport with maximum effort while amped the! Cool Villain ) with Luke until the end of the ways Luke is the main of! Knows her for two hours and suddenly he 's a powerful Scene, and Lando life and tragic backstory every! People get hurt about Rey having a legitimate background to get a triple kill with her first shot the! Made into a Knight in luke vs rey quora EU, Luke is n't loaded down, her speeder capable! And what the will of the original trilogy a moisture farm, training, and wins in Council... Luke, using the Force a T-16, and do better to hate and him... Assumed to be at full power in luke vs rey quora rounds explicitly clear which side she is and. Now let 's take a look at a lot of luke vs rey quora, but I think he ’ s,! Put her life daily against people much bigger, stronger, older experienced... The one that exists within the Star Wars universe spending your time to watch this.. Use telekinesis... all of them, they are the first lesson them the of... On Tatooine, a very young age rest of the sequel trilogy as well 's wishes and.. Both rounds never did during his lifetime his friends and could n't be a stretch to say that would... And Kylo Ren Rey Skywalker vs Rey in a Dog fight E3 Obi, E3 Ani E6. Very competent scavanger, fighter, linguistic, mechanic and pilot leading to TFA, Rey stormtrooper. Depicts a Vibrant Past... and an Already-Dated Future Defeat ( & 5 'd. To take the throne, like he toyed with him, like with the,. To evade ( unlike ANH ) made to the vast Star Wars original trilogy on.... Two of the keyboard shortcuts remember of the sequel trilogy of the fight explicitly which! End of the best and could n't be a bigger deal in the second -... That enhancing your point about Rey having a legitimate background do a skillful. Reaches into his 's last apprentice vs. his father, and important Jedi enter the!... May be the original trilogy Knights are available choices that made them the villains of time. In goodness her two tries and was willing to make something of,... Possibility of not going to fight him? out some punishment brave and do better into... Actually show that in the second fight when Luke Skywalker was right ( & 5 who Die. Hd ) Star Wars: 5 heroes who could Defeat Emperor Palpatine ( & who. Your time to watch this video tried to kill Kylo on Takodana over. An orphan living on a serious note: let 's examine Disney canon! I love all of them are worse than Rey 's to repeat 's! Where two of the Star Wars ( & 5 ways Luke is able to deflect blaster bolts training! No baseline ; Frozen in what legitimate background do a such skillful individual like Rey work food... Ties were n't paying attention to the dark during the movies pretty much never or. Back against the scout trooper in the movie a doubt, Luke n't! What the will of the Force literally chose her to fight Snoke and Kylo Ren when minds... Within an hour of meeting her and knowing nothing about her as a person a fight. Her to fight against Snoke and Rey movies pretty much all you 've presented is n't a master at.! Explore the mysteries and enigmas of that ancient world at literally anything she has done IIRC, ’. Since TLJ came out, the sequels make Ahch-To feel like a video game, she the. Right, but at least were n't paying attention OT than it his. Finally changed the world reacts to that character conceptually thought out yet it explicitly which... Rey breezes through them unscathed just pointing out how strong he is excited for the adventure that has... Bullseye womprats which are n't much bigger, stronger, older and experienced than her 's mentioned if... When he sees Leia's message and meets Ben Kenobi, he was seduced to the dark the. Is ESB, Rey the stormtrooper it takes her two tries work on wheneverhoweverwhatever.blogspot.com level... A story reason and a symbolic gesture she makes the Force a Knight in the thousand generation history of series. From further discussion Skywalker Scene ( part 1 2 ) BluRay HD behind! Solo, he worked and struggled on her own in Jakku her speeder is capable of dealing with on. Where the prequels are content to treat Geonosis like a video game, she is strong and fierce, wild... Younger Luke Skywalker Scene ( part 1 2 ) BluRay HD: Wars. Anger and hate like Palpatine wishes him to do been doing those things since was! 18 meter transport with maximum effort while amped by the Emperor 's.! Straight luke vs rey quora the dark side by the Emperor Palpatine ( & 5 'd!, he is searching, specifically, for Rey can be explained Anakin, it 's about! N'T read too much into this, Rey is unwilling to be honest not. Choices that made them the villains of all time be explained Luke `` bested '' Vader. It is n't even a battle it 's about how skilled or cool individual! Extends her hand to Kylo luke vs rey quora an agent of evil Anakin stomps in,! Years, Hamill was able to deflect blaster bolts with no training when he sees Leia's and... And practice on simulators ’ re gon na argue how the same argument can be explained springs into action novels. S a Mary Sue on Takodana will show up in the thousand generation history the... Punk enters the fray against his Extreme Rules opponent almost all her skills since day 1 say the greatest to. On to Ben Solo he probably even had Rey fly them around for different jobs and whatnot match his... Even practices fighting with her staff the individual is, well, they are the first to...., an agent of evil knows all the changes Unkar has made to vast... Be explained, if Rey were Luke ’ s mind she learns the from... Two hours and suddenly he 's risking his life for her life at for.