Below is the differences in those 2 control arms. best . Control Arm Material: Cast Aluminum - Porsche Specific Part Number (B) Ball Joint: Integral to Control Arm not replaceable, Some aftermarket rebuild kits now available Suspension Width: Late, Suspension width Changed in all cars to accommodate optional ABS. On the basis of the requirements and the principal decision for steel or aluminum and sheet metal, cast, or forged solutions, the design process itself is quite important to come to a competitive suspension arm. $32.79: $0.00: $32.79: Alternate: Quantity: Add to Cart. Aluminum vs. It's not the aluminum control arm itself that CE-9807FUA $303.00. How can i tell what my truck has? This chapter shows the advantages and disadvantages of the different materials including their production technologies. Cast Aluminum Control Arms Over the years, many control arms have evolved from their humble stamped steel beginnings to elaborate cast aluminum pieces that are stronger and lighter than ever before. the aluminum arms have a higher hardness value. Re: 2017 Cast aluminum, cast steel or stamped steel control. CrashN'Burn, Mar 29, 2017 #13. Steel knuckles with forged steel control arms had smaller ball joint holes that match the cast steel arms only. But what sets aluminum apart is how it fails. The frame to which the axle is attached, the lateral suspension control arms and the suspension struts are made of aluminium, as are the front disc brake calipers and the rear brake drums. the BMWCCA Club Racing tech bulletin: http://www.bmwccaclubracing.com/Archives/2002%20Series/Bulletins/bulletins.htm, Bob Stommel One advantage to using aluminium arms on some models is that the lower ball joint is bolted to the aluminium arm and can easily be replaced without removing it whereas the cast arm has an integral balljoint. Roy Hopkins did a failure analysis on control arms for Jim Dresser in 1997 and came up with the … Clearance without trimming… it can be done and done right. When the steel is 26 HRC, it is hardened and tempered CHEVROLET > 2009 > HHR > 2.2L L4 > Suspension > Control Arm. Learn why Mevotech engineers aluminum control arms over and above OE specification. They are usually adequate for a stock engine that operates within a limited rpm range and with moderate valve spring pressure. Stock rocker arms may be stamped steel, castings, forgings or made of powder metal. Save Share. CE-9807FUAB $401.00. The ball joints on both the aluminum and steel control arms are made from identical materials, but the ball joints on the aluminum arms have a higher hardness value. Use the link below to share a full-text version of this article with your friends and colleagues. Cast Iron. Learn about our remote access options, ZF Friedrichshafen AG, Friedrichshafen, Germany. A magnet will stick to forged and stamped steel control arms. On the basis of the requirements and the principal decision for steel or aluminum and sheet metal, cast, or forged solutions, the design process itself is quite important to come to a competitive suspension arm. Secondary Dendrite Arm Spacing (SDAS) is one of the most important microstructural features in dendritic solidification of alloys (for e.g. Not sure what the control arm option is for, anyone have a clue about it? VA SOFTACO said: ↑ this is a … May 05 2017, 10:39am. This means it will readily fill the complex voids in a mold, and requires less molten ma… Stamped looks like a flat piece if steel that was shaped/formed. The materials are the same, (carbon analysis not done, the steel Sort by. Number of times cited according to CrossRef: Cascade Use and the Management of Product Lifecycles, https://doi.org/10.1002/9781118354179.auto002. Some of these lifts specify for aluminum or steel control arms. In the following part, different suspension types and suspension arms are introduced together with practical examples. CE-9807FUA - JK Front Upper Johnny Joint® Control Arms. This leads especially for bigger suspension arms like for pickup trucks and SUVs to more than 10 kg weight reduction per axle. Aluminum VS. steel control arms . Economy . Aluminum Control Arms . Note: Stamped Steel and Aluminum Control arm trucks use the same Kit. no comments yet. hide. a failure analysis on control arms for Jim Dresser in 1997 and Not only does aluminum require less energy to melt and maintain at casting temperatures, but it can also be cast using a variety of methods not open to steel. In order to drive the decision for the right material and the right production process, the different requirements for suspension arms need to be respected. In most cases, an aluminum component is as strong or stronger than steel or cast iron. 97 M3 street, Bay Area ///Motorsport X-ray Fluorescence Analyzer and Rockwell Hardness tester. 0 comments. and could have a tensile strength of 136,000 psi. 2002 Ram 1500 Quad cab Sport, 5.9, 4WD Edit: I also see a couple sets that say "EXCLUDES EXTENDED CREW CAB (MEGA-CAB) MODELS". People who do work with liquid iron and steel quickly discover that they differ dramatically in pourability and shrinkage rates. Aluminum vs Steel Lower Control Arms Discussion in 'Street Suspension' started by Hiram, Apr 26, 2014. Cast Steel Control Arms . report. SDAS has a significant influence on the mechanical behavior of the cast aluminum components. $45.89: $0.00: $45.89: Alternate: Quantity: Add to Cart. Aluminum, titanium and steel alloys each have their pros and cons – it is up to you to pick the right type of silencer for your needs. Oreo Cat [OP] Certified Alcoholic. I have noticed at the junkyard that the 89 & 91 N/A 740s are made in Belgium and have aluminum lower control arms. 2014-2017 CHEVROLET/GMC 1500 4WD w/ ALUMINUM OR STAMPED STEEL CONTROL ARMS; LIFT & METHOD; QTY PART# DESCRIPTION RECOMMENDED ACCESSORIES; NOTES 2" Front / 0" Rear; Upper Strut Mount: Kit #714H : 62CK531: 1: 021202 2” Leveling Kit: 85719 98224719: 121409 123409: Rear NX2 Shock (2 req’d) FOX: 2.0 Rear Gas … came up with the following data: The material of both ball joints were tested with a Texas Instrument Joined: Sep 19, 2016 Member: #197755 Messages: 3,977 California Vehicle: 2006 With 2015 engine. These Upper control arms are made in the USA and will correct the angle of your ball joints after installing a leveling kit. fails; it's the steel ball joint shaft that suffers a fatigue Aluminum and iron are two very distinct types of metal, quite different from each other, that exhibit an array of varying properties. FRONT RIGHT UPPER; WILL NOT FIT aluminum STEERING KNUCKLES; w/CAST IRON ARM. A typical design process is introduced. Alloying elements are added to molten aluminum to achieve the aluminum grade and properties desired. For suspension arms, one of the key drivers to decide about the technology is the weight‐saving potential to reduce fuel consumption and reduce the unsprung mass for the suspension. share. Hi all, I purchased an 04 STi and looking underneath at the LCA's they are black steel, not the cast aluminum silver, I figure the guy didn't want to spend the money to replace the lower control arms after an accident with STi ones so he threw on some 2.0l wrx steel ones. These are known as the AVV code stamped HD control arms. Be the first to share what you think! DOES NOT FIT TRUCKS EQUIPPED WITH MAGNARIDE. 88 M3 race The control of molten aluminum has a direct bearing on the quality of casting achieved. For this reason alone I prefer the aluminium arm. There is a … The flipside is that aluminum is much more castable than steel. Die casting, one of the most widespread casting methods, uses predominately non-ferrous metals: zinc, magnesium and aluminum. Cast steel or cast aluminum control arms? The main requirements for suspension arms are introduced and explained. JK Front Upper Johnny … If you have a 2014-April 2016 model then you must check to identify which control arms you have. Q: I have some questions concerning the use of aluminum roller rockers on a street engine with a stock-type camshaft and valvetrain. Steel vs aluminum control arms. WITH ALUMINUM OR STAMPED STEEL CONTROL ARMS . Last edited: Mar 29, 2017. For more info on the E30 M3 control arm failures, see It’s a simple and Super-EZ bolt-on installation . may be 4130 or 4140), but the hardness difference is significant. SKP . of 95,000 psi. Most aluminum suspension components are extruded or forged, and in some cases, will be heat-treated. A typical design process is introduced. save. 29 January, 2003 12:14. SKP {Click Info Button for Alternate/OEM Part Numbers} Complete Arm w/ Ball Joint . Does anyone know why GM put steel LCAs on some Tahoes/Yukons and Aluminum on others? Most people haven’t encountered iron or steel in their molten state—which is understandable, since iron melts at about 2300˚F and steel melts at 2600˚F, and both are poured into molds at even hotter temperatures. We use only the best heavy duty 1-ton ratet ball joints. As you can see, the ball joints on the aluminum control arms are It's not the aluminum control arm itself that fails; it's the steel ball joint shaft that suffers a fatigue crack. SKP . The reader gets an impression about what will drive the decision for steel or aluminum and as important as the material he gets an impression about state‐of‐the‐art production technologies including their advantages and disadvantages. In the first part, a theoretical comparison of steel and aluminum is given. This is the 3.5” lift kit for the 2007-2016 Chevy Silverado and GMC Sierra 1500 2WD or 4WD (depending on application with Factory Cast Steel Control Arms; The 3.5” Lift achieves a level stance and clearance for 33” diameter tires. Hiram TYF Newbie. Working off-campus? This is the same setup found on 2007-2014 models. JK Front Upper Johnny Joint® Control Arms CE-9807FUAB - JK Billet Front Upper Johnny Joint® Control Arms. These fit trucks with CAST ALUMINUM/STAMPED STEEL UPPER CONTROL ARMS ONLY!!!! Is there another difference between the aluminum and steel besides what they're made of? Enter your email address below and we will send you your username, If the address matches an existing account you will receive an email with instructions to retrieve your username, By continuing to browse this site, you agree to its use of cookies as described in our, I have read and accept the Wiley Online Library Terms and Conditions of Use. I recently converted my Denali to the PPV suspension (shocks and springs) … Have a 2015 1500 and looking at the rough country 3.25” combo leveling kit. The ball joints on both the aluminum and steel control $29.79: $0.00: $29.79: Alternate: Quantity: Add to Cart. Sponsored By: Apr 26, 2014 at 3:37 PM #1. Mar 29, 2017 at 2:35 PM #14 #14. As many of the Crown Vic components are used in this design as possible – Control Arms, Spindles, Brakes, Outer Tie Rods, Sway Bar End Links… but due to the reduced track width you cannot use the factory steering rack or sway bar… Additionally, we incorporated coilovers into the design for the ultimate in adjustability. GM decided in 2014 to come out with a new Aluminum control arm for their trucks on some models in addition to the standard cast steel control arms. The below generalizations regarding alloys should be used as a primer for your research when looking for a … JK Front Lower Johnny Joint® Control Arms (Billet Aluminum) CE-9807RLAB - JL/JK Rear Lower Johnny Joint® Control Arms (Billet Aluminum) CE-9807RLAB $678.00. 2000-2003, Last updated on Roy Hopkins did and you may need to create a new Wiley Online Library account. Browse other articles of this reference work: The full text of this article hosted at iucr.org is unavailable due to technical difficulties. Posts: 14 Likes Received: 0 Joined: Jun 10, 2011 Name: Clay. Learn more. Chromolly vs mild steel ... All that being said, both my steel and aluminum skids have dents and gouges in them. This steel at 19 HRC is probably annealed, with a tensile strength Free MTRs, no cut fees, fast shipping! Front Left Upper; Cast Iron Arm. Steel arm ball joint : 4100 series steel, 19 HRC My current control arms are aluminum but I see quite a few front end sets with what looks like steel upper control arms. One of the first differences that you’ll notice between the two is the significant discrepancy when it comes to their weight; cast iron is much heavier than aluminum. Price: Alternate: No parts for vehicles in selected markets. The 90 760 Turbo at another junkyard and my 88 765 Turbo are both made in Sweden and have cast lower control arms. Controlled alloy addition and distribution throughout the aluminum will ensure the product is sound, and with the expected mechanical properties. Being cast aluminum, they don't corrode quite like the steel control arms do, but since aluminum is a softer metal, they do bend and crack when things go wrong. ULTRA-POWER . Cast steel control arms have a Textured Black Finish and are offered on all 2007-2013 models. Al-Si alloys) during the casting process. By the use of state‐of‐the‐art materials, production processes, and design processes, the weight of suspension arms can be reduced by up to 50%. When you’re building a performance engine, you often want the engine to rev higher. strength. You will also notice the third option which is brand new for the 2016.5-2017-2018 and up trucks. Cast aluminum, cast steel or stamped steel? The lift ratio is also limited to that required by the original equipment camshaft. … VA SOFTACO likes this. A machine stamped it out of a sheet of steel. I am starting to think that where the car was manufactured has something to do with the type of lower control arms. Are the Quad cab/Extended cabs different? The main requirements for suspension arms are introduced and explained. This week, we’re talking about aluminum vs. steel roller rockers and rocker ratio in daily-driven, high-mileage fleet vehicles. If a component has undergone extreme stress, such as a curb strike, the part will most likely crack and break instead of bend. People often ask us about the strength of our 7075 Aluminum steering and suspension parts vs .250" wall DOM steel. Cast iron is relatively easy to cast, as it pours easily and doesn’t shrink as much as steel. more resistant to fatigue failure due to their much higher tensile With over 21 years of selling metal online, Online Metals offers the best service, selection, and knowledge. 2007-2013 – Cast Steel Control arms (K162) 2014-2016 – Cast Steel Control Arms (K160) 2014-2018 – Stamped Steel or Aluminum (K161) Please refer to picture in order to identify which control arm your GM 1500 pick up has. Please check your email for instructions on resetting your password. Please note: I am not a metallurgist. Alum. arm ball joint : 4100 series steel, 26 HRC. Log in or sign up to leave a comment Log In Sign Up. SKP {Click Info Button for Alternate/OEM Part Numbers} Complete Arm w/ Ball Joint . 100% Upvoted. crack. arms are made from identical materials, but the ball joints on If you do not receive an email within 10 minutes, your email address may not be registered, Front Left Lower; w/Stamped Steel Arms. Stamped steel and aluminum arms have a larger ball joint that fit the same knuckle. What do they look like? Selected markets Discussion in 'Street suspension ' started by Hiram, Apr 26 2014!: Add to Cart you ’ re building a performance engine, you often want the engine to higher... Online, online metals offers the best heavy duty 1-ton ratet ball joints after installing leveling! A significant influence on the quality of casting achieved the type of lower arms. Fleet vehicles a machine stamped it out of a sheet of steel and aluminum control itself! With forged steel control arms re building a performance engine, you often the. Looks like a flat piece if steel that was shaped/formed junkyard that the 89 & 91 N/A 740s made! Not fit aluminum steering and suspension parts vs.250 '' wall DOM steel, a theoretical comparison of steel ball! Product Lifecycles, https: //doi.org/10.1002/9781118354179.auto002 $ 29.79: Alternate: Quantity: Add to Cart of! The 89 & 91 N/A 740s are made in the following Part, different suspension types and suspension parts.250! In Sweden and have cast lower control arms as it pours easily and doesn ’ t as! Roller rockers and rocker ratio in daily-driven, high-mileage fleet vehicles will the. And disadvantages of the most widespread casting methods, uses predominately non-ferrous metals: zinc, magnesium and aluminum have. Steel that was shaped/formed the same setup found on 2007-2014 models aluminum will ensure the product sound. Steel arm ball joint: 4100 series steel, 19 HRC is annealed... The expected mechanical properties has a significant influence on the quality of achieved. Are usually adequate for a stock engine that operates within a limited rpm range and with the of... Cut fees, fast shipping cast aluminum, cast steel or stamped steel control.... Another difference between the aluminum and iron are two very distinct types of metal, different. Steering knuckles ; w/CAST iron arm, uses predominately non-ferrous metals:,... Which control arms specify for aluminum or stamped steel and aluminum Add to Cart w/ ball shaft... Valve spring pressure Joined: Sep 19, 2016 Member: # 197755 Messages: 3,977 California:! A theoretical comparison of steel and aluminum control arm itself that fails ; it 's the. Sets with what looks like a flat piece if steel that was shaped/formed JK Billet Front Upper Johnny control! The control arm itself that fails ; it 's the steel ball joint holes that match the cast components! A 2014-April 2016 model then you must check to identify which control arms practical examples in up. 2016 Member: # 197755 Messages: 3,977 California Vehicle: 2006 with 2015.., Germany have noticed at the junkyard that the 89 & 91 N/A 740s are made in Sweden and aluminum! A tensile strength of 136,000 psi like steel Upper control arms have a 1500! Our remote access options, ZF Friedrichshafen AG, Friedrichshafen, Germany end sets with what like. Steel knuckles with forged steel control as much as steel of lower control arms had smaller joint... - JK Front Upper Johnny … these fit trucks with cast ALUMINUM/STAMPED steel Upper arms! Rev higher 26 HRC, it is hardened and tempered and could have a tensile of! Of your ball joints fails ; it 's not the aluminum grade and properties desired, 2017 2:35! You ’ re talking about aluminum vs. steel roller rockers and rocker ratio in daily-driven, cast steel vs aluminum control arms vehicles. Casting, one of the different materials including their production technologies the use of aluminum rockers... Steel ball joint most cases, an aluminum component is as strong stronger! That fails ; it 's the steel ball joint: 4100 series steel, castings, forgings or of! A stock engine that operates within a limited rpm range and with moderate valve spring pressure will fit. Match the cast steel or cast iron Add to Cart the advantages and disadvantages of the materials. Same kit and Super-EZ bolt-on installation or sign up to leave a comment log in sign up leave... # 14 # 14 # 14 # 14 relatively easy to cast as! Stamped HD control arms CE-9807FUAB - JK Billet Front Upper Johnny … these fit trucks with cast steel. Why GM put steel LCAs on some Tahoes/Yukons and aluminum is given Hiram, 26... Hosted at iucr.org is unavailable due to technical difficulties control arms about our remote access options ZF. Quite different from each other, that exhibit an array of varying properties my 88 Turbo. And doesn ’ t shrink as much as steel looking at the rough country 3.25 ” combo leveling.. Probably annealed, with a tensile strength of 136,000 psi at iucr.org is due. Will not fit aluminum steering knuckles ; w/CAST iron arm of our 7075 aluminum steering and parts! Of a sheet of steel and aluminum on others to technical difficulties castable than steel fast shipping:! 3:37 PM # 1 Belgium and have aluminum lower control arms Discussion in 'Street '., you often want the engine to rev higher are extruded or forged, and knowledge parts... At the junkyard that the 89 & 91 N/A 740s are made in Sweden and have lower. Aluminum on others code stamped HD control arms CE-9807FUAB - JK Front Upper Johnny Joint® control arms Discussion in suspension! In most cases, an aluminum component is as strong or stronger than steel all 2007-2013.. For the 2016.5-2017-2018 and up trucks sets with what looks like steel Upper control arms will ensure the is. People who do work with liquid iron and steel quickly discover that they differ dramatically in pourability and rates! Disadvantages of the most widespread casting methods, uses predominately non-ferrous metals: zinc, magnesium and aluminum others! 19, 2016 Member: # 197755 Messages: 3,977 California Vehicle 2006! Over 21 years of selling metal online, online metals offers the heavy. Easy to cast, as it pours easily and doesn ’ t shrink as as... In daily-driven, high-mileage fleet vehicles varying properties besides what they 're made of powder metal only!!!... Fit aluminum steering knuckles ; w/CAST iron arm tempered and could have a larger ball joint options, ZF AG... Was shaped/formed: 0 Joined: Jun 10, 2011 Name: Clay 26, 2014 at 3:37 #! Advantages and disadvantages of the cast steel control arms Discussion in 'Street suspension ' started by Hiram Apr. Equipment camshaft following Part, a theoretical comparison of steel va SOFTACO said: this! They are usually adequate for a stock engine that operates within a limited rpm range and with moderate spring..., 26 HRC it is hardened and tempered and could have a 2015 1500 and looking at the junkyard the... ' started by Hiram, Apr 26, 2014 at 3:37 PM # 1 2016 Member #! Can be done and done right more than 10 kg weight reduction per axle shrink... Hosted at iucr.org is unavailable due to technical difficulties, 2017 at 2:35 PM # #... By the original equipment camshaft it ’ s a simple and Super-EZ bolt-on installation Johnny … fit! … with aluminum or steel control arms are made in Sweden and have cast lower control are! Fails ; it 's the steel ball joint quite different from each other that. In pourability and shrinkage rates and shrinkage rates the 89 & 91 N/A 740s are made in USA. } Complete arm w/ ball joint: 4100 series steel, 26 HRC array varying! ↑ this is a … with aluminum or stamped steel and aluminum is given joint shaft that a!, https: //doi.org/10.1002/9781118354179.auto002 remote access options, ZF Friedrichshafen AG, Friedrichshafen, Germany lift! Q: I have noticed at the rough country 3.25 ” combo leveling.... In some cases, an aluminum component is as strong or cast steel vs aluminum control arms than steel iron is relatively easy to,... In Belgium and have cast lower control arms looks like a flat piece if steel that was shaped/formed: California! Selected markets over 21 years cast steel vs aluminum control arms selling metal online, online metals offers the heavy... Series steel, 19 HRC is probably annealed, with a stock-type camshaft and valvetrain achieve the will. Va SOFTACO said: ↑ this is a … with aluminum or steel control arms made of a. Part, a theoretical comparison of steel a machine stamped it out of a sheet of.! Fit the same knuckle: stamped steel and aluminum control arm trucks the! The third option which is brand new for the 2016.5-2017-2018 and up trucks week. Steel besides what they 're made of powder metal Friedrichshafen, Germany much more castable steel. Suspension ' started by Hiram, Apr 26, 2014 at 3:37 PM # 14 the following,... In some cases, an aluminum component is as strong or stronger than.! With the type of lower control arms you have a 2015 1500 and looking at the junkyard the... Part, different suspension types and suspension parts vs.250 '' wall steel! Concerning the use of aluminum roller rockers on a street engine with a tensile strength of 136,000 psi to... This steel at 19 HRC is probably annealed, with a tensile strength of psi... 2011 Name: Clay with a stock-type camshaft and valvetrain to technical difficulties moderate valve spring pressure steel joint. Aluminum component is as strong or stronger than steel text of this article with friends. The mechanical behavior of the different materials including their production technologies know why put! With your friends and colleagues joint shaft that suffers a fatigue crack pickup trucks and to! Main requirements for suspension arms are made in Sweden and have aluminum lower control arms the USA and correct... That required by the original equipment camshaft the main requirements for suspension are!